Chapter 33.
July 25, 2026 at 4:42 PM
October 11, 1986. The "Lake Shore Limited" train, somewhere between New York and Chicago. Night.
Lisa couldn't sleep.
She lay on the top berth of the compartment, her cheek pressed to the cool wall of the car, listening to the rhythm of the wheels. The steady, rhythmic clatter usually lulled her on trips, but not tonight. Tonight, every click echoed dully in her head, as if the wheels were beating out not the rhythm of the tracks but something else—a warning she couldn't decipher. Outside the window, utter darkness slid past, occasionally pierced by the distant lights of farms, the glass vibrating slightly.
Below, Max slept. His breathing was heavy, with occasional snores—he'd fallen asleep as soon as his head hit the pillow, but even in sleep his fingers twitched, as if still gripping his knife handle. Jenny slept on the adjacent berth, curled into a ball, her hand pressed to her chest—where the locket with the letter "B" hung beneath her shirt. Arthur lay by the window, and Lisa knew he wasn't asleep, though he didn't move and his breathing was even. She could feel his insomnia as acutely as her own—in the barely perceptible tension in his shoulders, in the way he blinked too slowly, staring at the ceiling.
Sasha and Rachel had settled in the adjacent compartment. Rachel had insisted on it—said it would be safer that way: "Two adults covering the flanks, the children sleep in the center." Lisa didn't like it. Not that she completely distrusted Rachel—she was a Circle agent, said the right things, knew details only an insider could know. But something about her was off. Something Lisa couldn't put into words but felt with her skin—like a draft from a slightly open window that doesn't go away even when the window is closed.
She climbed down from the berth, trying not to make noise. Her bare feet touched the cold floor. Max muttered something in his sleep and turned over, the springs creaking. Arthur didn't move, but Lisa noticed his eyes glint in the darkness—he was staring at the ceiling.
"Can't sleep?" she whispered.
"No."
"Me neither."
She sat on the edge of his berth, tucking her legs under her. The train lurched at a rail joint, and Lisa braced her hand against the cold wall to keep from falling. The upholstery smelled of dust and stale tobacco.
"What do you think of Rachel?" she asked.
Arthur paused.
"I don't know. She knows her job. Talks like an agent."
"That's not an answer."
"What answer do you want to hear?"
Lisa looked at him. There was almost no light in the compartment, only a dim strip from the corridor under the door, but she could see his face well enough to understand: he was hiding something. Something gnawing at him from the inside.
"Arthur."
"Yeah?"
"You know something. Something you're not telling me."
He didn't answer right away. The train lurched again, and an empty glass clinked on the shelf. Somewhere far away, in another car, a child cried—a thin, piercing sound that quickly faded.
"Tucker gave me a list," Arthur said, his voice quiet, almost a whisper. "Call signs for Circle agents on the East Coast. Clean agents. Rachel was on it."
"And you trust her? Because of a list?"
"I..." He hesitated. "I don't know."
Lisa felt cold spread inside her. Not because of his words—because of how he'd said them. Uncertain. Like someone who'd already made a decision and was now doubting whether it had been the right one.
"Did you verify the list with Sasha?"
"No."
"Why not?"
"Because Tucker said they were clean agents. Because I..." He exhaled, closing his eyes. "Because I thought, 'He's a sergeant. He knows better.' And I put the list in my pocket and forgot about it."
"And today?"
"Today Rachel showed up, and I remembered. And I thought, 'She's on the list. So I can trust her.'"
Lisa was silent. In the quiet, the rhythm of the wheels seemed louder than usual—or maybe it was her blood pounding in her ears.
"That was stupid," she said at last. "You said yourself: 'Don't trust people in uniform.' And now you're trusting a piece of paper."
"I know."
"What are you going to do?"
"For now—nothing." Arthur sat up, swinging his legs down. "She's a Circle agent. Maybe Tucker is right. Maybe I'm just being paranoid. Maybe..."
The compartment door opened.
Lisa flinched. Arthur stopped mid-sentence. In the doorway, silhouetted against the dim corridor light, stood Rachel. She was fully dressed—her dark blue suit buttoned up, her hair still slicked back. As if she hadn't gone to bed at all. She smelled of lavender and that same metallic, coin-like scent.
"Can't sleep?" she asked. Her voice was even, businesslike, without a trace of drowsiness.
"We're discussing plans," Arthur said. His voice had changed—it was harder, more adult. Lisa watched him square his shoulders, as if putting on the mask of a leader.
"Commendable." Rachel stepped into the compartment, closing the door behind her. "But I have urgent business. Arthur, I need the dagger."
"Why?"
"A security check." She spoke quickly, clearly, in a tone that brooked no argument. "There'll be an inspection at the next station. Police looking for contraband. If they find the dagger, we'll have problems. I'll hide it in the baggage car until the check is over."
Lisa frowned.
"What police? We're crossing three states, no one inspects anything here."
"I have my sources." Rachel didn't even glance at her. She was looking only at Arthur. "I've been working this route for two years. I know where and when the checks happen."
Arthur hesitated. Lisa could see it—saw his fingers grip the edge of the mattress, saw the muscles in his jaw clench.
"Arthur," she said quietly, "wait."
"We don't have time to wait," Rachel cut in. "The station is fifteen minutes away. Give me the dagger, and I'll return it as soon as the train pulls out."
Arthur looked at Lisa. Then at Rachel. Then he reached into his backpack and pulled out the dagger—the very one wrapped in cloth, with its worn hilt and dark blade. In the dim light, it looked almost black.
"Here," he said, handing it to Rachel. "But I want it back in half an hour."
"Of course." Rachel took the dagger. Her fingers lingered on the blade for a second—or did Lisa imagine it?—then she tucked it into the inner pocket of her jacket and left without another word.
The door closed. The compartment went dark again.
"Why did you do that?" Lisa whispered.
"Because she's on the list." Arthur's voice sounded hollow, as if from underwater. "Because she's a Circle agent. Because if I don't trust my allies, who can I trust?"
"Me. Max. Jenny. Sasha." Lisa gripped his shoulder. "Us."
Arthur didn't answer. He lay back down, staring at the ceiling. Lisa wanted to say something more but couldn't find the words. She climbed back to her berth and wrapped herself in her blanket, though she wasn't cold.
Rachel returned half an hour later. Arthur took the dagger, checked it—the blade was intact, the hilt the same, the cloth the same. Rachel nodded and went to her compartment. Arthur tucked the dagger into his backpack and closed his eyes.
But Lisa didn't sleep. She lay there, listening to the rhythm of the wheels, and it seemed to her that the rhythm had changed—become heavier, deeper, as if the train wasn't heading to Chicago but somewhere downward, underground.
October 12, 1986. The "Lake Shore Limited" train. Morning.
Lisa woke first. Outside the window, the gray fields of Ohio slid past—flat, dreary, dotted with sparse islands of bare trees. The sun was just rising, its light pale, diluted by clouds, falling on the windowsill in watery yellow patches.
She climbed down from her berth, stretching until her spine cracked. Max was still asleep. Jenny sat by the window, reading Martha's diary, her lips moving silently. Arthur stood in the corridor with a cup of coffee from the dining car—steam rising from the plastic cup, and he stared at it as if the answers to all his questions were hidden in that steam.
Lisa walked to her backpack to get her sketchbook. And froze.
The dagger lay in its place, wrapped in the same cloth. But something was wrong. She unwrapped the fabric.
The blade had changed. The engraving on it—the very one Lisa had sketched in the circus—had become blurred. Not erased, not scratched—blurred. As if someone had run a wet brush over it. The lines had bled, lost their sharpness, and from them emanated a faint, barely perceptible smell. Sweetish. Like rot.
"Arthur."
He turned.
"Look."
He came over, took the dagger. His face changed—not fear, but something else. Cold understanding. His fingers tightened around the hilt.
"What is it?" Jenny asked, setting down the diary.
"I don't know," Arthur said.
"It's not just smudged." Lisa ran her finger over the blade without touching it. "It's like... a wound. As if the dagger is injured."
"Or infected," Jenny said quietly.
Max woke at the sound of their voices and sat up, his hair sticking out in all directions.
"What happened?"
"Rachel," Arthur said. It didn't sound like a name—it sounded like a curse.
He turned and stepped into the corridor. Lisa followed. They reached Sasha and Rachel's compartment. Sasha sat by the window, cleaning her pistol—the slide disassembled, an oily rag on the table. Rachel was not there.
"Where is she?" Arthur asked.
"She went to the dining car." Sasha looked up. "Why?"
Arthur set the dagger on the table. Sasha looked at the blade, and her fingers froze on the slide. For a second, such a silence fell over the compartment that the clatter of the wheels was deafening.
"Who touched it?"
"Rachel," Lisa said. "Last night. Arthur gave her the dagger for a security check."
"What security check?"
"She said there would be a police inspection. That the dagger needed to be hidden."
Sasha slowly set down the pistol. The metal clinked against the table.
"There are no police inspections on this route. I've worked this line for three years. Not one check in all that time."
A silence fell over the compartment. The clatter of the wheels seemed thunderous.
"She's on the list," Arthur said, his voice dead. "Tucker gave me a list of clean agents. Rachel was on it."
Sasha closed her eyes. For a second—just a second—her face lost its usual composure, and Lisa saw something else beneath the hunter's mask. Weariness. Or anger. When she opened her eyes, they were cold.
"Tucker doesn't know everyone," she said. "Lists get outdated. Agents get turned. Or they die, and their names are used by others. You should have shown me the list."
"I know," Arthur said.
"And you didn't."
"I know."
Sasha stood, holstering the pistol in one sharp motion.
"I'll find her. You stay here and don't touch the dagger. If what I think is true, it's now dangerous."
She left. Lisa stared at the dagger, at the blurred engraving, at the faint vapor rising from the blade. And she felt a cold, heavy certainty growing inside her: whatever Rachel had done to the dagger, it was only the beginning.
In the corner of the compartment, by the door, she noticed a shadow.
Shadows on a train were ordinary—from suitcases, from shelves, from passengers. But this shadow didn't belong to any object. It rippled, flowed, and something flickered deep within it—like an eye watching them from the darkness. From it emanated that same sweetish smell.
"Arthur."
"I see it."
The shadow twitched and vanished, as if it had never been there. Only the smell remained—it had soaked into the seat upholstery, the curtains, the air. Lisa raised her hand to the spot where it had just been and pulled her fingers back—the air there was ice-cold.
The train carried them toward Chicago. And something was riding with them.